⚾️🏈 The Prop Queen Newsletter

MLB & NFL Props on September 12th, 2025

Hi subscribers! Below are today’s Matchups to Watch, MLB pitcher props and a couple of NFL props for this weekend.

All premium subscribers have access to the MLB Prop Spreadsheet as well. This includes strikeout, outs, hits allowed and earned runs props. Access the spreadsheet here. If you want to learn how to use the spreadsheet, you can see the tutorial here.

Make sure to subscribe to the Prop Queen Sports YouTube Page!

Sign up today for Props.Cash using promo code PROPQUEEN for 50% off your first month AND a chance to win a jersey of your choosing!

ARIEL’S CORNER

🔥 Matchups to Watch

Good Matchups

William Contreras - .333 (3-9) with 2B, HR vs. Andre Pallante

Gunnar Henderson - .364 (4-11) with 2 HR vs. Chris Bassitt

Taylor Ward - .313 (6-15) with 4 2B vs. Luis Castillo

Jose Ramirez - .313 (5-16) with HR vs. Martin Perez

Kyle Schwarber - .364 (8-22) 2 2B, 2 HR vs. Michael Lorenzen

Josh Bell - .500 (6-12) 2B, HR vs. Mitch Keller

Eugenio Suarez - .417 (5-12) with 3 HR vs. Yusei Kikuchi

Bad Matchups

Brice Turang - .400 (4-10) 2B vs. Andre Pallante

Mookie Betts - .100 (3-30) 2B, 3 Ks vs. Justin Verlander

Shohei Ohtani - .217 (5-23) 2 2B, 2 HR and 10 Ks vs. Justin Verlander

Mike Trout - .182 (2-11 with HR, 6 Ks vs. Luis Castillo

Luis Rengifo - .227 (5-22) with 3 HR vs. Luis Castillo

Subscribe to Prop Queen Sports to read the rest.

Gain access to this post and other subscriber-only content.

Already a paying subscriber? Sign In.

Subscribers Can Gain Access To:

  • • Help make your prop betting process simpler!
  • • Get access to the morning newsletter so you don't miss analysis of the best lines
  • • Receive an updated afternoon newsletter with fresh injury insights and prop betting analysis closer to game time
  • • Updated charts and data useful for making educated prop bets
  • • Exclusive MLB prop spreadsheet hitting around 60 percent each season