⚾️🏈 The Prop Queen Newsletter

MLB & NFL Props - September 26th, 2025

Hi subscribers! Below are props for tonight in MLB. Since this morning’s premium newsletter, I’ve included Matchups to Watch and some early looks into the NFL for this weekend.

Don’t forget to subscribe to the Prop Queen YouTube Channel! Today’s show included MLB and College Football bets with Mid Major Matt.

Free subscribers will see today’s fishy pitcher prop lines.

Sign up today for Props.Cash using promo code PROPQUEEN for 50% off your first month AND a chance to win a jersey of your choosing!

ARIEL’S CORNER

🎣 Pitcher Props Fishy Lines

BAL LHP Trevor Rogers Under 5.5 Ks -144

Orioles at Yankees - 7:05 PM ET

I HATE back-to-back starts against the same team for this reason. Rogers just threw a gem against the Yankees in his last start going six innings of one hit shutout baseball with seven strikeouts and two walks. That shouldn’t happen again, hence the juice on the under. Rogers is averaging a full strikeout less on the road this season. Although the Yankees strikeout a lot more against lefties, they’re on a mission for the division and hitting the ball well. I can see the Yankees beating up on Rogers to the point he can’t stay in long enough to hit six strikeouts.

TOR RHP Shane Bieber Under 6.5 Ks -124

Rays at Jays - 7:07 PM ET

I am beyond confused by this number. Bieber has gone under 6.5 Ks in five straight starts and all three at home. 73% of the last 20 right handed pitchers to face the Rays have gone under their strikeout prop. Only one right hander in the last 10 has hit over 6.5 strikeouts. Righties are 49-61 o/u averaging 4.49 strikeouts per game against Tampa this year. 6.5 just seems WAY too high, but why is it so high?!

The Prop Queen newsletter is sponsored by Pikkit! Just click this link, use promo code PROPQUEEN and sync your sportsbooks to track your bets for FREE! Follow me at ArielEpstein.

Subscribe to Prop Queen Sports to read the rest.

Gain access to this post and other subscriber-only content.

Already a paying subscriber? Sign In.

Subscribers Can Gain Access To:

  • • Help make your prop betting process simpler!
  • • Get access to the morning newsletter so you don't miss analysis of the best lines
  • • Receive an updated afternoon newsletter with fresh injury insights and prop betting analysis closer to game time
  • • Updated charts and data useful for making educated prop bets
  • • Exclusive MLB prop spreadsheet hitting around 60 percent each season