Honest confession: afternoon baseball used to be my least favorite thing to bet on.

Then I started pulling afternoon data separately. Pitchers have completely different profiles at 1:35 PM than they do at 7. Once I built a dedicated afternoon K list — ranking every starter by day game performance since 2024 — the slate went from my least favorite research day to one of the most reliable parts of my week.

Today there are 23 pitchers on it. Here's a taste of what's inside:

The No. 1 ranked arm this afternoon averages 7.1 Ks per afternoon start — but the line is set where 79% of his afternoon games have gone under. That's not an accident. The books know exactly what they're doing with that number.

Meanwhile there's a lefty sitting at No. 4 with an 80% over rate on his afternoon prop. Nobody's talking about him. That's the point.

I already did all the work. You just have to use it.

Today’s Afternoon K List

The Prop Queen Afternoon K List - May 24th, 2026
The Prop Queen Afternoon K List - May 24th, 2026
Every afternoon, before the first pitcher takes the mound, I rank every starting arm on the slate by how they've actually performed in afternoon games since 2024 — not ERA, not season stats. Day ga...
$8.99 usd

🔒 Already a premium subscriber?

It's already in your inbox. Go check it.

Not premium yet? This is included — plus everything else that lands daily.

— Ariel aka the Prop Queen

Ariel Epstein, known as the Prop Queen, turned her passion for fantasy sports and prop betting into a career. After years of working for other media companies and sportsbooks, it’s time to share her knowledge, preparation and analysis with other sports bettors.